© 2019 Los Angeles Review of Books. Nietzsche puts an end to the brutal scene, throwing his arms around the horse s neck, sobbing. He had been living a transitory existence for some years, having all but excluded himself from positions at German universities due to his irreligious thought and his provocative writings. Nicht allzu weit weg von ihm hat der Kutscher einerPferdedroschke Ärger mit einem … mehr. German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche witnessed the whipping of a horse while traveling in Turin, Italy. März 2012 im Basis-Film Verleih. One day in Turin in 1889 Nietzsche beat up a hansom cab driver who was savagely whipping his horse. The Turin Horse [Blu-ray] [UK Import] 13,25€ 2: January 3, 1889: Nietzsche Witnesses the Flogging of a Horse: 1,26€ 3: I Am Dynamite! If you are capable of loving, and of feeling and sharing the pain of a creature as pitiful as a horse, then surely only love for mankind can follow. Jahrhunderts, https://de.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Das_Turiner_Pferd&oldid=201987282, „Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike“, Nominierung für Béla Tarr in der Kategorie. 2016 belegte Das Turiner Pferd bei einer Umfrage der BBC zu den 100 bedeutendsten Filmen des 21. Diese Seite wurde zuletzt am 18. This fabled story begins with Nietzsche leaving his lodging in Turin, Italy. "The Turin Horse" veranschaulicht an vielen Beispielen die unbewusst ausgeführten tagtäglichen Rituale, die - Tier - Mensch - und - Natur - über sich ergehen lassen müssen - bis - eines Tages, eines nach dem anderen seine "Arbeit" einstellt. Der Titel des Films bezieht sich auf eine Anekdote, die am Filmanfang vom Erzähler berichtet wird: Friedrich Nietzsche soll im Januar 1889 unmittelbar vor seinem geistigen Zusammenbruch in Turin ein streikendes Droschkenpferd mit theatralischer Geste vor der Peitsche des wütenden Kutschers bewahrt haben. (It is hard to say whether it helps or hinders the thesis of compassion that Nietzsche, in his final years of madness, was supposed to have unendingly repeated a few terse phrases, including “I do not like horses.”) It is tantalizing for his readers to imagine that, by embracing a horse, he was ending his career as a philosopher and writer as a spectacular failure — he was confessing, not in words but in action, that we cannot slip so easily out of the confines of compassion. Not far from him, a cab driver is having trouble with a stubborn horse. Die Tochter weigert sich, trotz Aufforderungen ihres Vaters, die Kartoffel zu essen. True or not, it is now part of how we understand his life, and it is now a rock, easily thrown by his critics, which might knock down those structures of his thinking we find might less palatable today. Not far from him, a cab driver is having trouble with a stubborn horse. Als auch noch die Petroleumlampe erlischt, bleibt nur Dunkelheit zurück. This is an idea that is especially tantalizing. It was co-written by Tarr and his frequent collaborator László Krasznahorkai. Dazu verschiedene Tatsachen, die ich im Verlauf meiner Suche ausmachen konnte: Nummer Produktname Preis; 1: The Turin Horse [Blu-ray] [UK Import] 13,25€ 2: January 3, 1889: Nietzsche Witnesses the Flogging of a Horse: 1,26€ 3: I Am Dynamite! It has been convincingly argued that Nietzsche’s works amount to a philosophy of aestheticism — that he commands us to live life as one would write literature. Breaking into tears, he slumped to the floor. In his diaries, under an entry relating to the “Russian Society for the Protection of Animals,” Dostoevsky offers an illustration of the manner in which our relation to animals reflects our ethical relation to other humans. On January 3, 1889 in Turin, Italy, Friedrich Nietzsche steps out of the doorway of number six, Via Carlo Albert. Als ein unablässiger Sturm durch das Land zieht, verändert sich das Leben der beiden notgedrungen. Crying, he runs forward and looks the horse directly in the eye, and in doing so, is caught by a lash from the whip. There are several reasons why this story might have become so ingrained in the popular understanding of Nietzsche. Nietzsche puts an end to the brutal scene, throwing his arms On January 3, 1889 in Turin, Italy, Friedrich Nietzsche steps out of the doorway of number six, Via Carlo Albert. It is a meditation on Nietzsche who, in Turin in 1889, was said to have seen a horse being thrashed, and protectively threw his arms around the beast, then sobbingly collapsed due to … Der Schwarzweißfilm feierte seine Premiere am 15. With Erika Bók, János Derzsi, Mihály Kormos, Ricsi. Friedrich Nietzsche went mad after allegedly seeing a horse being whipped in the Italian city of Turin. (I am reminded of lines from William Blake’s “Auguries of Innocence”: “A Horse misused upon the Road / Calls to Heaven for Human blood”.) But note that there is no coachman whatsoever in Fino’s version of events, and that the very suggestion that the horse might have been suffering at the hands of anyone has trickled into the narrative during its retelling. The Turin Horse [Blu-ray] [UK Import] 13,25€ 2: January 3, 1889: Nietzsche Witnesses the Flogging of a Horse: 1,26€ 3: I Am Dynamite! Béla Tarr ‘s The Turin Horse is built around a legendary act of cruelty. Nietzsche’s readers who share this view seem to want to believe he threw his arms around that horse, in part because it can be seen as a final flourish to complete his life’s writings (and the writing of his life), but in part because it seems so fatally to contradict large areas of his thought. Am sechsten Tag sitzen der Bauer und seine Tochter am Tisch, wo sie rohe Kartoffeln zu sich nehmen wollen. Die Werckmeisterschen Harmonien | Undoubtedly Nietzsche was found in the street, and there are multiple firsthand accounts that detail Nietzsche’s subsequent mental decline and his spell in a mental asylum shortly after. Den Hauptteil des Filmes macht die Schilderung des Lebens einer armen Familie von Kartoffelbauern Ende des 19. A Torinoi Lo - Béla Tarr - 2011 - 1080p; By Believe_in_Not_Believing . Was aus dem Pferd geworden sei, sei unbekannt.[1]. Nietzsche runs to throw his arms around the horse’s neck - a defensive act, bursts into tears, and collapses onto the ground. Perhaps Nietzsche did have horses on his mind when he stepped into the square on that January morning, and was drawn by some impulse towards one. Beide wechseln nur wenige und notdürftige Wörter miteinander. The Man from London | Raskolnikov, in the voice of a child, pleads with the men to stop. Given the circumstances, it is easy to imagine that Nietzsche may well have been weeping — thus the addition of his tears to many of the versions seems broadly permissible. I detect an odd specter of Nietzsche in The Turin Horse, though it’s more of an anti-Nietzsche. Nietzsche, who directed his philosophy against Schopenhauer’s conceptions of pity and empathy, would appear to be bearing witness to the cracks in his own reasoning if he himself, in a moment of radical pathos, is brought trembling and weeping to his knees by a beaten nag. The Turin Horse von Béla Tarr „Am 3. In less than one month, Nietzsche would be diagnosed with a serious mental illness that would make him bed-ridden and speechless for the next eleven years until his death. On January 3, 1889, in the throes of a manic episode, Friedrich Nietzsche left his lodgings in Turin, walked a short distance across a nearby square, and then halted. Nietzsche's Horse: 11,28€ 11: The Turin Horse [Blu-ray] [UK Import] 13,25€ 12: January 3, 1889: Nietzsche Witnesses the Flogging of a Horse: 1,26€ 13: I Am Dynamite! And around the same time, Nietzsche was having his own dreams of horses. But whatever did … —IMDb Editors. When was the idea for the film born? The story of the Turin horse was thus told 11 years after the event it purports to describe, by an unnamed reporter, who recounts a version of events spoken to Nietzsche’s landlord by an equally nameless police officer. It recalls the whipping of a horse in the Italian city Turin which is rumoured to have caused the mental breakdown of philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche. Nevertheless, he rises, dresses, and prepares to commit murder. A rural farmer is forced to confront the mortality of his faithful horse. All rights reserved. Showing all 2 items Jump to: Summaries (2) Summaries. The Turin Horse [Blu-ray] [UK Import] 13,25€ 2: January 3, 1889: Nietzsche Witnesses the Flogging of a Horse: 1,26€ 3: I Am Dynamite! Then he lost consciousness and slid to the ground, still clasping the tormented horse.”, “Nietzsche threw his arms around the horse’s neck, tears streaming from his eyes, and then collapsed onto the ground.”, “As Nietzsche fell on the pavement, he threw his arms around the neck of a mare that had just been flogged by a coachman.”, “Nietzsche had just left his lodgings when he saw a cab-driver beating a horse in the Piazza Carlo Alberto. Das Pferd hört auf zu fressen und schließlich zu trinken, der Brunnen versiegt, das Feuer im Herd brennt nicht mehr. Jahrhunderts den 63. His rage was incandescent, bestial. In Turin his hosts were the Fino family, and in their house, in the extraordinarily productive year leading up to the famous incident with a horse, Nietzsche wrote what are remembered as some of his greatest works. His father scoops him up and drags him away from the horse, against his will, and suddenly Raskolnikov awakes, cold and sweating. Raskolnikov, who will imminently butcher two old ladies with an axe, is anxiously laid up in bed. Strange, then, that there is actually very little evidence that there ever was such a horse. The central image of his life that has proven so tenacious, that of the weeping Nietzsche embracing a horse, is perhaps the most difficult to prove. Die Monotonie der Bilder, die Wiederholung der Handlungen und die sich langsam ausbreitende Resignation entwickeln eine Sogkraft, der man sich schwer entziehen kann.“, Internationale Filmfestspiele Berlin 2011. The report reads: One day when Mr. Fino was walking along the nearby Via Po — one of the main streets of Turin — he saw a group of people drawing near and in their midst were two municipal guards accompanying “the professor.” As soon as Nietzsche saw Fino he threw himself into his arms, and Fino easily obtained his release from the guards, who said that they found that foreigner outside the university gates, clinging tightly to the neck of a horse and refusing to let it go. The horse refuses to move, whereupon the driver loses his patience and takes his whip to it. Die Landschaft ist karg, die Arbeit und der Tagesverlauf eintönig und gleichförmig. For one, he provides his own links between his pre-madness biography and the works of Dostoevsky. Családi tűzfészek | If so, the horse and its owners share in Nietsche’s ultimate fate — a sort of death of spirit. Raskolnikov throws his arms around the bloodied muzzle and kisses it around the eyes, calling in vain for the barbarism to stop. 1889. Der Sturm lässt schließlich nach. Der Titel des Films bezieht sich auf eine Anekdote, die am Filmanfang vom Erzähler berichtet wird: Friedrich Nietzsche soll im Januar 1889 unmittelbar vor seinem geistigen Zusammenbruch in Turin ein streikendes Droschkenpferd mit theatralischer Geste vor der Peitsche des wütenden Kutschers bewahrt haben. Panelkapcsolat | There is also the fact of the symbolic potency of the horse. He details one in a letter of 1888: “winter landscape. But there is only a single source that brings a horse into the picture. Szabadgyalog | By the writing of the novel, when Dostoevsky was 44 years old, he came to view the story as a formative memory: “My first personal insult, the horse, the courier.” Fittingly, then, a similar episode resurfaces in Dostoevsky’s final novel The Brothers Karamazov, in the chapter “Rebellion.” In that work, a story is told of a horse that cannot pull its cartload; the owner “beats it, beats it savagely, beats it at last not knowing what he is doing in the intoxication of cruelty, thrashes it mercilessly over and over again.” We are told that the story is “peculiarly Russian.” Surprisingly, we also discover that these words are adapted from “lines from Nekrasov” — a reference to the poem “O pogode” (“About the Weather”) by Nikolai Nekrasov, in which a “hideously lean” horse is beaten to death in front of a laughing mob. Every blow that rained down on the animal was the direct result of every blow that fell on the man.”. But the year was also marked by his increasingly erratic behavior; he would sing and play for hours at a piano, often tunelessly; he would, allegedly, dance boisterously in the nude around his room; the Finos even discovered torn and discarded money in his waste-paper basket. Tearfully, the philosopher flung his arms around the animal’s neck, and then collapsed.”. The Turin Horse is Tarr’s last film, so if you haven’t seen any of his movies before, ... Perhaps this sickly horse is the one that Nietzsche saved. Mit jedem Tag wird den beiden ein Stück ihrer Lebensgrundlage entzogen. 1889. The passage in question occurs early on in Dostoevsky’s great work Crime and Punishment. He was almost arrested for disturbing the peace, but was rescued by his landlord and was taken back home and to bed. As the cruelty escalates and the horse collapses, it becomes clear that it will die. نوشته و هماهنگ شده با این نسخه از فیلم: The Turin Horse - 2011 - Limited - 1080p Bluray - x264 - Rovers Subtit Őszi almanach | In unserer Rangliste finden Sie tatsächlich nur die Liste an Produkten, die unseren strengen Qualitätspunkten gerecht werden konnten. (Fino doesn’t actually mention a collapse either, but letters circulating amongst Nietzsche’s friends at the time make it clear that a fall took place.) Das Turiner Pferd (Originaltitel: A Torinói ló) ist ein Spielfilm des ungarischen Regisseurs Béla Tarr aus dem Jahr 2011. A rural farmer is forced to confront the mortality of his faithful horse. The cabbie, in turn, mercilessly begins to flog his horses with a “terrible fist”: “the coachman, who could barely hold on because of the blows, kept lashing the horses every second like one gone mad; and at last his blows made the horses fly off as if possessed.” The young Dostoevsky’s own cabbie, shaking his head at the scene, tells him that this was quite usual, and that “the lad, perhaps, that very day will beat his young wife: ‘At least I’ll take it out on you.’” Dostoevsky serves this up as a stark example of how violence breeds violence, and injustice breeds injustice. German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche witnessed the whipping of a horse while traveling in Turin, Italy. Jahrhunderts aus: Geschildert wird das Leben eines alten Bauern und seiner erwachsenen Tochter auf einem kleinen Gehöft über einen Zeitraum von sechs Tagen. The horse episode held special significance for Dostoevsky, originating, as it did, in his own life experiences. — To ‘give style’ to one’s character — a great and rare art!” If Nietzsche advises, above all, that we should cultivate our lives and our selves as we would create a work of art, what might it mean for his own life to so neatly replicate a literary work? The Turin Horse (2011) Plot. "The Turin Horse" setzt ein mit einem Monolog aus dem Off, in dem von Nietzsches bekanntem Vorfall im Turin des Jahres 1889 berichtet wird: Er … The above is a fairly uncontroversial telling of the episode, which is generally considered an important one within his intellectual history: it marks a definitive moment, between great philosopher and broken mind. Handlung. Many times, a writer, in order to prove a point or deepen the significance of his work, looks for a nice bite-sized snippet from a piece previously written by a great mind. Verdammnis | Nietzsche was 44 years old in when he suffered a collapse in Turin — coincidentally the same age as Dostoevsky had been when he wrote Crime and Punishment. He writes, for instance, in The Gay Science, that “One thing is needful. It might be tempting to over-emphasize the role of Nietzsche’s horse in his life precisely because we feel forced to read it as a focal point of compassion. Ko-Regie führte seine Ehefrau Ágnes Hranitzky, die auch für die Montage verantwortlich war. But for The Turin Horse, it really is more of a novel than a script that he wrote. The tale is apocryphal, likely hovering more in the realm of fiction than of fact. After uttering his final words, "Mutter, ich bin dumm" ("mother, I am stupid"), Nietzsche becomes mute and demented, cared for by his family until his death a decade later. Men climb into the cart to weigh it down further, and the owner continues to whip and to shout “Gee-up!” When someone speaks up against the violence, he merely yells “My property, my property!”. Nekrasov’s poem was composed after Crime and Punishment — therefore Dostoevsky’s own horse seems real enough, even though he would later draw on another writer’s image of a beaten animal. We already understand it. He assaulted the driver and could have killed him — would have had he not been pulled off by others. 1889. Nietzsche-inspired, obviously, and Tarr's themes of the hopelessness of existence are laid bare, but by that point in The Turin Horse it is unnecessary. Mit Erika Bók, János Derzsi, Mihály Kormos, Ricsi. He tossed his arms around the horse's neck to protect it then collapsed to the ground.